Medical malpractice bill exempting 'free' doctors fails

A bill that seeks to exempt doctors who offer free medical care from malpractice lawsuits has failed to pass in the final legislative session in another state. In an election year in which medical malpractice reform is a hot topic in the Washington D.C. area and around the country, this particular bill, as do many medical malpractice reform efforts, has fierce support and opposition.

Opponents argue that this bill is unfair to low-income consumers because it prevents those who seek free medical care from pursuing a medical malpractice claim against a doctor. The bill leaves only those who can afford to pay for health care with the right to sue for such medical malpractice as hospital negligence, surgical mistakes and drug errors. Doctors who volunteer their time were strong supporters of the bill.

The bill received much testimony in the state legislature, including attorneys from the New Jersey Association for Justice, which is a trial lawyers group, who argued the bill would create two classes in society, one which can pursue justice through the courts and one which cannot. Every citizen should have access to quality health care as well as justice, it said. The group also argued that so called "free" health care would no longer be free in that the costs for a patient is giving up his or her legal rights.

The legislation, which would have provided immunity to doctors who provide free medical treatments from medical malpractice lawsuits, did not provide immunity for "gross negligence or willful misconduct." Supporters said the bill would prevent retired doctors who volunteer their time from having to purchase malpractice insurance. The legislation providing civil immunity would also make it easier to recruit doctors, mainly specialists to work at free clinics to expand services offered, supporters argued.

The Federal Tort Claims Act covers doctors at community health centers, federally qualified health centers and free clinics. The FTCA provides for individuals to sue the federal government for medical malpractice, personal injury, wrongful death and property damage caused by the negligence of federal employees or independent contractors, under certain conditions, who are performing work within the scope of his or her employment duties.

Victims can sue for monetary damages for a specified amount governed by federal law however, state law, where the negligence or omission occurred may dictate the government's liability in such matters as medical malpractice. State laws vary greatly in terms of medical malpractice guidelines and caps on monetary damages awarded.

Source: NJ Spotlight, "Malpractice Exemption Pits Lawyers Against Volunteer Doctors," Beth Fitzgerald, June 25, 2012

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Steven H. Dorne

Attorney Steven H. Dorne

Attorney Steven H. Dorne is an accomplished lawyer who practices in state and federal courts in Maryland, Virginia and the District of Columbia. He brings more than 30 years of experience and a long record of success to each case. His law practice is distinguished by careful preparation and thorough analysis of each case...

Learn More
  • Virginia Trial Lawyers Association
  • ABA
  • Trial Lawyers Association Of Metropolitan Washington D.C | Working For Justice
  • Maryland Association For Justice
  • American Association For Justice
  • MSBA

Call Or Email For A Free Consultation

If you have suffered a personal injury in a car crash or other accident, need help with another type of dispute, we are prepared to help. Contact our lawyer online or call 877-234-4179 to schedule an initial consultation. There is no cost or obligation to contact us. Se habla español. For your convenience, we have offices in Washington D.C., Rockville, Greenbelt and Fairfax.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Rockville Office
200-A Monroe St.
Suite 100
Rockville, MD 20850

Toll Free: 877-234-4179
Phone: 301-637-8078
Fax: 301-251-0730
Map & Directions

Rockville Office

Washington D.C. Office
1150 Seventeenth St. NW
Suite 305
Washington, D.C. 20036

Toll Free: 877-234-4179
Phone: 301-637-8078
Fax: 301-251-0730
Map & Directions

Washington Office

Capital Office Park
6305 Ivy Lane
Suite 408
Greenbelt, MD 20770

Toll Free: 877-234-4179
Phone: 301-637-8078
Fax: 301-251-0730
Map & Directions

Greenbelt Office

Fairfax Office
10521 Judicial Dr.
Suite 303
Fairfax, VA 22030

Toll Free: 877-234-4179
Phone: 703-722-6446
Fax: 301-251-0730
Map & Directions

Fairfax Office
  • Toll Free 877-234-4179
  • Maryland/D.C. 301-637-8078
  • Virginia 703-722-6446
  • Fax 301-251-0730
Back To Top